CLICK HERE to subscribe to our weekly emails on finding and brewing amazing coffee!
Most aspiring home baristas and out-and-out coffee fanatics probably cringe at the idea of an automated brewing device that pumps out java while we twiddle our thumbs.
If you’re a regular Roasty reader, you’ll know that we don’t really recommend Keurig coffee makers in general, and suggest that you actually make good coffee using methods such as pour over or French Press.Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.
I realize that many of you don’t care what I think… and you want to buy the ultra convenient Keurig anyway. If that you, we’ll do our best to help you pick the best Keurig coffee maker for the money.
At a Glance: Our Top 5 Picks for Keurig Coffee Makers
- Keurig K575 Single Serve Programmable K-Cup Coffee MakerOUR TOP CHOICE
- Keurig B145 OfficePRO Brewing System
- Keurig K155 Office Pro Coffee Maker
- Keurig K475 Single Serve Coffee Maker
- Keurig K55 K-Classic Single Serve Coffee Maker
Keurig K250 Coffee Maker, Single Serve K-Cup Pod Cof…$229.99 (1786)
Keurig K145 OfficePRO Brewing System with Bonus K-Cup Por…$169.00
It’s really just a matter of deciding which of Keurig’s many models would best suit your needs. And with so many to choose from, just knowing where to start can be a daunting prospect. To muddy the waters even further, Keurig upgrades its products twice every year!
So, we’ve put together this comprehensive, informative guide to the very best Keurig coffee makers that are currently available. Whether you want to upgrade your existing machine or you’re about cave and get your first Keurig, here’s all you need to know.
Quick Summary: The Best Keurig Coffee Makers
First off, what is Keurig?
Keurig is a household name in the world of coffee machine manufacturing. They also make extras, including carafes, filters, and coffee consumables to complement their home and office coffee machines.
The company created their signature coffee maker back in the early 1990s for use in an office setting. Since then, the range has expanded and Keurig machines are now a staple in many US kitchens.
Now, Keurig machines come in a somewhat bewildering range of models and colors to suit all budgets and requirements. However, the result is the same; pretty good tasting coffee and a smart, understated coffee machine that will look cool on any countertop.
Why would you need one?
What makes Keurigs so popular is the fact that they can give users hot coffee fast without sacrificing too much flavor. Their machines are simple to use and reliable, many are programmable, and they’re pretty low maintenance.
Granted, you won’t get the same precise control over your brew that drip machines or a French press give you. However, what a Keurig coffee maker can guarantee is consistency, convenience, and speed. Plus with around 160 flavors to choose from, you’re bound to find some that you enjoy.
All Keurig coffee making machines will make you a brew in under one minute, an essential consideration for those who need a coffee first thing in the morning before heading out to work. Even better, many Keurig’s are fully programmable too, so you can set your coffee maker to deliver your early morning cup of Joe before you even get out of bed.
Of course, if you want high-quality specialty coffees such as latte, cappuccino, and espresso, you may need to opt for a semi-auto or super-auto espresso brewer. However, these machines are significantly more expensive than most Keurigs, and might not suit your budget.
Other important considerations are ease of use, ease of cleaning, and ongoing maintenance. A Keurig is a whole lot easier to manage than an espresso machine on all counts.
Why Your Local Coffee Shop ISN’T Using One
So, you may be wondering why you don’t usually spot Keurig on the Top 10 lists for coffee makers. Like we mentioned, Keurigs and other pod brewers like, Illy and Nespresso, can be great if you need something fast with minimal clean-up.
But there are some things you are trading in for that convenience. And it’s mainly the taste of your coffee. An equally convenient super-automatic espresso machine or even a good drip brewer is going to make you a WAY better cup of coffee. But some of those can run you about 10 times the price of a Keurig.
There are other options though! If you are hesitant to go for a pod-brewer but don’t know what else is out there that would be comparable, we encourage you to take a look at some of the following manual brewing methods and tools:
- Aeropress: Very fast, easy cleanup, some technique
- Clever Coffee Dripper: Zero technique, decently fast, easy cleanup
- French Press: Slower process, bigger servings, cold brews
- Pour Over: More technique, slow process, easy cleaning
Several of these options, when combined with an electric kettle and a grinder, will brew you a cup of coffee that’s worlds better than what any pod brewer could achieve. Also, they won’t be hogging your counter space.
Plus, sometimes taking a little time for yourself with the perfect a cup of coffee in the morning is a great way to practice self care. However, if your lifestyle really doesn’t allow for that luxury, we understand your choice in going for a pod brewer. So let’s get into that, shall we?
All Keurig machines work in basically the same way. You fill the water tank, insert your chosen coffee pod, and place your chosen cup size under the dispenser, press the “go” button, and wait for your brew to be delivered.
Additionally, there are a few features that you can expect regardless of which model you choose, including:
- A removable drip tray: This allows for easier clean-up and extra space for you mug if needed
- One-minute brew time: While the time it takes for the machine to heat up varies, all Keurigs take about one minute to actually brew your coffee.
- Compatibility with Keurig pods only: This includes a couple different types of pods, but you won’t be able to venture out into other brands very easily.
- Removable water reservoirs: Keurig water reservoirs, while their size varies, are all removable. This feature makes for easy refilling and cleaning.
- Auto-off: Coffee makers have a heating element, which eats power if left permanently switched on. The auto-off feature powers-down the machine after a pre-set period (from 1 minute to 2 hours) from its last use. All Keurigs have this feature, but the extent of programmability varies.